Husqvarna Motorcycle tests
(1) Paper. Oiled
foam and fabric filter elements are used in dirt bikes and other offroad
applications, instead of paper filters commonly found in cars and
household air filters, because they have the capacity to
hold lots of dirt and continue to keep air flowing. Motorcycle
foam filter oil and fabric filter oil starts out as basic petroleum,
synthetic or plant/vegetable-based oil. Oils marketed as biodegradable
or “bio” are plant-based, but still have some old-fashioned petroleum
too. No-Toil claims to offer the only 100-percent plant-based filter oil
on the market.
Plant-based. Synthetic oils are very pure and withstand high heats. Companies who use
synthetic oils feel like they saturate the filter more evenly and
completely. Plant-based oil has several advantages. It is biodegradable
and nontoxic, which is compromised when blended with petroleum products.
It is easier on your filter, and the foam won’t degrade as quickly.
Plant-based oils make cleaning filters easier.
(3) Motor oil. If you
are in a real pinch, you could use regular motor oil on your air filter.
It is better than nothing. If you are old-school, you have probably done so on many occasions. The
problem is that motor oil pools in the airbox, distributes itself
unevenly and can be sucked through the intake tract. Air filter oil has
special additives blended with the oil to solve these problems.
Alcohol. Isopropyl alcohol is commonly used to help the oil penetrate into the
pores of the filter better. It thins out the oil, making it watery and
easy to apply. But, it must be given ample time to evaporate before the
filter is used. Otherwise, the oil will get sucked into the intake or
even catch fire. Adding alcohol is troublesome, because it classifies
the oil as hazardous material. This complicates shipping, storage and
exporting. Alcohol also eats the cheaper glue on some filters. As an
alternative thinner, No-Toil developed an oil that’s temporarily bonded
to water, eliminating the need for alcohol. The drawback is a longer
(5) Tackifier. Another
additive is a “tacker” to help make the oil sticky. Some brands are
very tacky, while others argue that thinner oil actually performs
better. There is also a chemical that makes filters flame-resistant. DT1
weighed the performance and extra cost of adding an additional layer of
flame-resistant foam to their filter (as some other companies do)
against the flame-resistant oil; they chose the latter.
(6) Oiled versus dry. Twin
Air claims that their tests show, among other things, that a properly
oiled filter will flow more air than a bone-dry one and catch more dirt
than an over-oiled filter. DT1 has done tests that have shown a full
horsepower gain by minimizing the amount of oil on the filter. MXA tests
show that a slightly dirty filter is better than a freshly oiled
filter. Take your pick.
(7) Cleaner. The
type of air filter cleaner used depends on the type of filter oil used.
Some cleaners are solvents that cut through petroleum-based oils. After a
petroleum-based oil is removed, the filter is still dirty and must be
washed with soap and water. Another type of cleaner is detergent made to
wash away plant-based oils. With plant-based oils, the harsh-solvents
step is skipped. The third type is common gasoline. It will cut through
oil better than any filter cleaner/solvent, but it will eat rubber
grommets, seals and glues, and degrade foam. After a couple gasoline
baths, a foam filter is limp and soggy feeling (even when dry).
(8) Application. The
recommended application method for most foam filter oil is to completely
saturate the foam and gently squeeze out the excess. Some filter
oil comes in a spray can that goes on with the press of a button, but
beware of trying to gain performance with a light coat. It will work,
but it may cost you. Fabric filters can use spray-on oil or a spouted
bottle to place a bead of oil on each pleat. K&N actually has a
chart for the optimal quantity of oil for each filter based on surface
(9) Storage. If
storing your filter oil for more than a day or two, always store it in a
metal container, because sealed plastic buckets are too porous. If the
oil dries out, it will turn to useless sludge. Although some companies
say not to pre-oil and store filters, most companies say it’s okay to
pre-oil and store your filters in a ziplock bag, as long as there are
some holes to let any alcohol evaporate. MXA always runs pre-oiled filters in our test bikes.
(10) Rain. MXA
has used just about every brand of filter oil, from Maxima’s super-tacky
FFT synthetic-based oil to No-Toil’s 100-percent plant-based oil. We
used to avoid bio-marketed filter oil, because it didn’t seem to stand
up to water spray. Today’s bio oils are much better, but we still
use petroleum filter oil for rain races.